Y&R’s Michelle Stafford Wins Holiday Bake-Off After Last Year’s Disappointment

Michelle Stafford may be known to The Young and the Restless fans for playing the fiercely competitive Phyllis Summers, but it seems the actress has a little of that winning spirit herself. After falling short in last year’s annual holiday bake-off, Stafford returned to the competition determined to take home the top prize. And this time, she wasn’t leaving anything to chance.
From late-night baking sessions to playful attempts at securing votes from her castmates, Stafford made it clear that she wanted another bake-off victory. Her confidence was unmistakable, even before anyone had tasted her entry. But did all that preparation pay off? As it turns out, the actress had plenty of reasons to celebrate when the competition finally came to an end.
Michelle Stafford Sets Her Sights on Bake-Off Victory
The holiday season brings a special tradition to the The Young and the Restless set. Each year, cast members and crew gather for an annual bake-off, giving everyone a chance to show off their culinary skills and compete for bragging rights.
It’s a festive opportunity for the people behind the daytime drama to step away from their usual work and enjoy some friendly competition. And Stafford is clearly someone who takes the occasion seriously.
The actress regularly participates in the event, but her experience last year left her with unfinished business. In 2025, Matt from the props department claimed the winning spot, while Stafford had to settle for watching someone else take home the recognition.
That result apparently stayed with her.
In an Instagram Story that has since expired, Stafford gave followers a glimpse into her preparations. Standing in her pantry, she announced that she had been spending the day baking because the annual The Young and the Restless holiday competition was happening the following day.
However, getting ready for the big event wasn’t exactly a smooth process.
Stafford admitted that some of her practice attempts had turned out “horrible.” Clearly, she wasn’t going to let a few unsuccessful trial runs discourage her. Instead, she kept working on her recipe, hoping to get everything right before the judges sampled her final creation.
The actress also took a moment to review the competition’s recent history. Matt from props had won the previous year, while Michael from accounting had taken the prize the year before that. Stafford herself had claimed victory in the competition before those wins.
She wasn’t shy about wanting to reclaim her place at the top.
“I believe I am going to come home with a ribbon tomorrow,” Stafford confidently declared.
It was a bold prediction, especially considering her earlier baking struggles. But the actress seemed convinced that her efforts would finally pay off.
A Berry Cobbler and Some Friendly Competition
When bake-off day arrived, Stafford was ready to put her preparation to the test.
Dressed comfortably in Christmas pajamas and a pink sweatshirt, the actress brought her submission to the festive gathering. Her chosen creation was a berry cobbler, and it wasn’t something she had thrown together at the last minute.
In fact, Stafford revealed that she had stayed up all night baking it.
That dedication certainly suggested she wasn’t treating this competition as a casual holiday activity. After last year’s disappointment, she wanted to give herself the best possible chance of winning.
As the cast and crew gathered to sample the different entries, Stafford made her way around the room, chatting with her colleagues and seemingly doing a little campaigning for her dessert.
One of her stops was Joshua Morrow, her onscreen ex-husband on the show. Stafford jokingly asked him whether he was going to watch her win the bake-off.
Morrow responded with a playful smile, saying, “Maybe.”
He then turned the conversation into a friendly challenge of his own.
“Are you going to win? I only hang out with winners,” he joked.
The exchange captured the lighthearted competitive atmosphere surrounding the event. Stafford was clearly confident in her cobbler, while Morrow wasn’t about to hand her a victory before the results were announced.
Of course, getting castmates to sample a dessert is one thing. Convincing them that it deserves the winning spot is another.
Mandi Line Praises Stafford’s Dessert
Stafford appeared to have at least one enthusiastic supporter during the tasting.
Costume designer Mandi Line wasn’t serving as a judge, but she was certainly impressed by the actress’s berry cobbler.
Line specifically praised the dessert’s dough and warmth, along with the dollop Stafford had prepared to place on top.
Her comments suggested that Stafford had paid attention to the details rather than simply relying on the recipe itself. The combination of the warm cobbler and its topping seemed to make a particularly positive impression.
For someone who had admitted that her practice attempts were less than successful, receiving such encouraging feedback must have been satisfying.
Still, compliments from colleagues didn’t necessarily guarantee that Stafford would win. The final decision was approaching, and everyone was waiting to discover which entry would receive the top honor.
Sharon Case Gives Michelle Stafford a Pep Talk
As the announcement drew closer, Stafford received another welcome boost from her longtime colleague and friend, Sharon Case.
Case offered some moral support, helping Stafford build excitement as the moment of truth approached.
“A lot rides on this,” Case said while encouraging her.
The comment was clearly delivered in the spirit of their friendly competition, but it also reflected just how invested Stafford had become in the outcome.
After spending hours preparing and staying up through the night to finish her cobbler, the actress had plenty riding on the result in her own mind.
Last year’s loss had given her extra motivation, and she was now just moments away from finding out whether all that effort would be rewarded.
Michelle Stafford Finally Gets Her Bake-Off Redemption
And the winner was… Michelle Stafford!
When her berry cobbler was announced as the winning dish, the actress couldn’t contain her excitement. Stafford screamed with delight and celebrated the victory alongside Case.
After confidently predicting that she would take home a ribbon, she had actually delivered on her promise.
The win was especially satisfying following her disappointment the previous year. Matt from props had taken the honors in 2025, but Stafford managed to reclaim the spotlight in the 2026 competition.
Her late-night baking session, unsuccessful practice attempts, and playful campaigning around the room ultimately became part of a very sweet victory.
It also gave Stafford another reason to embrace the competitive side that fans already recognize in her portrayal of Phyllis Summers. Whether she’s navigating Genoa City’s latest drama or trying to win a holiday baking contest, the actress clearly enjoys a challenge.
With this year’s result now in her favor, Stafford has every reason to feel proud of her accomplishment. And if her determination is any indication, she may already be thinking about defending her title when the next holiday bake-off rolls around.
After all, winning once is wonderful, but will Michelle Stafford be able to make it two victories in a row in 2027?







