Who Will Replace Joe Cruz on Squad 3? Chicago Fire Showrunner Teases a “Cool and Surprising” Plan

Season 14 of NBC’s Chicago Fire has delivered a non-stop wave of major changes inside Firehouse 51. Viewers have watched Kelly Severide officially step up as captain, said goodbye to former Chief Dom Pascal, met a revolving door of new CFD chiefs, and welcomed a fresh batch of firefighter candidates training under Stella Kidd. But no shift hits closer to home than the devastating blow dealt to Squad 3 following Joe Cruz’s warehouse fire injury—a tragedy that has left him sidelined, fighting to regain the use of his legs, and officially paving the way for Joe Minoso’s series departure.
With Cruz unable to return to active duty, Squad 3 is currently down to just three members: Severide, Capp, and Tony. The sudden vacancy on Firehouse 51’s elite unit has kept fans guessing about who will step into Cruz’s boots. Now, showrunner Victor Teran is finally addressing the spot left behind by the longtime firefighter.
Showrunner Promises a “Cool and Surprising” Addition
Speaking with Us Weekly, Teran confirmed that the series will explicitly address the opening on Squad 3 as Cruz makes his final exit. While keeping specific plot points strictly under wraps, the showrunner offered a tantalizing hint about what lies ahead, teasing that how the show handles the vacancy will be “cool and surprising.”
Teran’s cryptic statement leaves plenty of room for speculation as Captain Severide looks to rebuild his elite team. Because Squad 3 requires specialized skills and seamless teamwork, Severide could look to fill the slot with someone who already understands the high-stakes environment of Firehouse 51 and possesses proven synergy alongside Capp and Tony.
Could an Existing Firehouse 51 Veteran Make the Jump?
One intriguing possibility is that Severide chooses an internal candidate from within the firehouse walls. Transitioning a familiar firefighter like Vasquez or even a seasoned veteran like Christopher Herrmann onto Squad 3 would create an immediate shakeup in team dynamics.
Shifting a current member to Squad 3 would also open up a spot elsewhere in 51, providing an organic storyline to integrate one of Kidd’s new candidates—such as Burke—into a permanent role. Alternatively, the writers could break traditional CFD norms by promoting Burke directly to Squad 3 after his candidate rotation wrapped. While calling up a green firefighter to an elite squad would be highly unconventional, it would certainly align with Teran’s promise of a surprising twist and offer fresh narrative territory for the veteran unit.
The Case for Returning Favorites or a Brand-New Face
Another compelling direction involves bringing back a familiar face from Firehouse 51’s past. Among the potential candidates fans would love to see return, Kylie stands out as a strong contender. Watching her journey evolve from her early days in the Girls on Fire program to flourishing within the Chicago Fire Department has been a fan-favorite arc. Bringing Kylie back to join Squad 3 would mark a major milestone, making her the first woman ever to join 51’s elite squad while bringing meaningful representation to the unit.
Of course, the writers could also choose to introduce a completely new character to shake up the firehouse dynamic. While no major casting announcements have been made public yet, production teams often keep high-profile additions under wraps until episodes air.
As Firehouse 51 prepares to say a final, emotional farewell to Joe Cruz, viewers are left waiting to see which direction Severide and the CFD leadership will take—and who will ultimately take a seat on Squad 3.







