Marshals: Kayce Dutton’s Yellowstone Spin-Off Dominates Paramount+ for 164 Days Despite Taylor Sheridan’s Lowest Rotten Tomatoes Scores

Taylor Sheridan has spent nearly a decade proving that his brand of rugged, high-stakes storytelling operates by its own rules—and his action-driven Yellowstone sequel Marshals may be the clearest example yet. Even though the series carries the lowest Rotten Tomatoes scores of Sheridan’s television career, audiences have turned Kayce Dutton’s next chapter into a massive multi-platform hit, propelling the drama to 164 days in the Paramount+ Top 10 and the number-one spot overall on the streaming service.
That remarkable staying power highlights a striking divide between early critical skepticism and everyday viewer appetite. Following the October 4 debut of Season 2, Marshals has not only reclaimed the top perch on Paramount+ and outpaced Sheridan’s fellow action thriller Lioness on streaming, but it has also claimed the number-one ranking on “The Top Network TV Shows of 2025-26” charts.
How Marshals Turned Kayce Dutton Into a Streaming and Network Powerhouse
To appreciate how seamlessly Marshals captured viewers, it helps to look at the television empire Sheridan has built since transitioning from acclaimed big-screen thrillers like Sicario and Hell or High Water to television with Yellowstone in 2018. When Kevin Costner’s John Dutton first anchored that neo-Western saga—chronicling the family behind America’s largest ranch as they fended off internal fractures and outside land encroachers—few could have predicted just how vast the franchise would become.
Alongside hits like Landman, Tulsa King, and the fellow Yellowstone sequel Dutton Ranch, Marshals expands the universe by shifting its lens squarely onto John Dutton’s youngest son. Returning to the role that made him a fan favorite, Luke Grimes stars as Kayce Dutton in a story set roughly 15 months after the events of Yellowstone’s surprisingly divisive series finale.
Drawing on his background as both a seasoned Montana cowboy and a former U.S. Navy SEAL, Kayce joins an elite unit of U.S. Marshals tasked with delivering justice across Montana. By blending neo-Western atmosphere with brisk procedural action, the series tapped directly into the audience that made Yellowstone a phenomenon—keeping Marshals planted inside Paramount+’s Top 10 for 164 days and counting.
Taylor Sheridan’s Lowest-Rated Show Ever: Why Season 1 Divided Reviewers
For all its commercial momentum, Marshals has had a far rockier ride on review aggregators. In fact, the sequel currently stands as Taylor Sheridan’s lowest-rated series ever on Rotten Tomatoes, holding a “rotten” 48 percent score from critics alongside an even harsher 28 percent rating from audiences on the Popcornmeter.
Early detractors took aim at the series’ shift in tone and structure compared to the flagship drama:
- Missing Yellowstone’s Edge: Several reviewers argued that the spin-off lacked the distinctive “narrative spark” that elevated Yellowstone above standard television fare.
- Procedural Criticism: Other critics dismissed the show’s format more bluntly, characterizing the first season as a “dim procedural” that traded sprawling family drama for more conventional case-of-the-week storytelling.
Yet as the numbers on both broadcast television and Paramount+ make clear, Sheridan’s name—paired with Luke Grimes’s return as Kayce—proved more than strong enough to overcome rough initial reviews and keep millions of viewers tuning in week after week.
Season 2 Wins Warmer Reviews Ahead of the December 6 Finale
Even better news for fans of the series is that Marshals appears to be hitting a stronger creative stride in its second outing. Season 2 has drawn noticeably warmer feedback from critics than its inaugural run, with reviewers embracing its unapologetic, adrenaline-fueled identity and affectionately dubbing the show “SWAT in chaps and funny hats.”
That combination of momentum and improved critical reception puts the series in an enviable position as Season 2 nears its finish line. Following a brief hiatus, Marshals is scheduled to wrap up its second season on December 6.
Given its 164-day Top 10 streak on Paramount+, its number-one standing on network television charts, and a second season that has won over skeptics, a Season 3 renewal looks increasingly likely—though CBS and Paramount+ have not yet made an official announcement. Until word on the show’s future arrives, fans have plenty to watch as Kayce Dutton’s Montana unit charges toward its December 6 season finale.







