90 Day Fiancé: Molly Hopkins’ Daughter Olivia Faces Felony Theft Charge After Relatives Spot One-of-a-Kind Gift on eBay

Nearly a decade after viewers first met her as an outspoken teenager on TLC, 90 Day Fiancé star Molly Hopkins’ eldest daughter is facing the most serious legal trouble of her life. Olivia Hopkins, 27, has been arrested in Georgia on a felony theft by taking charge—marking her third arrest of 2026 and escalating a string of run-ins with law enforcement that far surpass her previous traffic offenses.
According to an arrest report and warrant obtained by Starcasm on November 19, 2026, authorities accuse Olivia of stealing personal property valued at more than $1,500 from relatives she had been living with and reselling the items online across eBay, Depop, and Poshmark. Cherokee County jail records show she was booked on October 27, 2026, before posting a $4,875 bond and being released the same day.
How a One-of-a-Kind Wedding Gift Allegedly Unraveled the Theft
The living arrangement at the center of the investigation began in spring 2026, when Olivia moved in with an older couple in the Hopkins family. While she stayed at the residence, the couple’s adult son and daughter-in-law also kept several of their own belongings stored inside the home.
According to the police records, suspicions first arose in May 2026 when the daughter-in-law spotted a distinctive, one-of-a-kind Winkler knife—which had been given to her husband as a wedding gift—listed for sale on eBay. Later on, after Olivia helped organize a basement room in the house, the son realized that two rifle scopes were missing. Both scopes soon surfaced on that very same eBay account.
When law enforcement reviewed the online listings, an investigating officer noted another telling detail: the carpet visible in one of the listing photos appeared to match the carpet in Olivia’s room.
Police took the initial report on October 10, 2026, while Olivia was away in New York, with the alleged thefts spanning from May 6 through October 11. During the investigation, the responding officer also advised the homeowners to begin the eviction process.
Inside the $3,179.98 Warrant Affidavit and Potential Georgia Penalties
The warrant affidavit outlines five specific missing items allegedly taken and listed for resale, carrying a combined estimated value of roughly $3,179.98:
- Crimson Trace scope: $1,229.99
- Winkler knife: Approximately $800
- The North Face jacket: $500
- Leupold scope: $399.99
- Ugg boots: $250
Under Georgia law, a felony theft offense involving property valued between $1,500.01 and $5,000 carries a potential prison sentence of one to five years, though a judge also has the discretion to treat the charge as a misdemeanor instead. While Olivia’s $4,875 bond is separate from the estimated value of the missing belongings, the charges in the warrant remain allegations rather than a finding of guilt.
From 90 Day Fiancé Season 5 to a Growing List of Georgia Arrests
Longtime 90 Day Fiancé viewers were first introduced to Olivia when Season 5 premiered on October 8, 2017. At the time, Olivia was 17 and her younger sister, Kensley, was 6, as their mother brought her fiancé, Luis Mendez, from the Dominican Republic to Georgia on a K-1 visa. Olivia frequently clashed with Luis on camera—a turbulent chapter that ended with Molly and Luis secretly marrying and then filing for divorce just five months later. In the years since stepping away from the franchise, Olivia has modeled for Molly’s LiviRae Lingerie brand and promoted an Atlanta club under the name Jade.
Off screen, however, Olivia’s legal record has steadily grown over the past six years:
- October 13, 2020: Olivia was charged with simple battery following an altercation at Molly’s Woodstock, Georgia home, with a warrant alleging she struck and kicked her mother.
- Late 2022: Olivia accused Molly’s then-boyfriend, former NYPD officer Kelly Brown, of choking her—an allegation that contributed to the end of Molly and Kelly’s relationship.
- February–April 2023: After pleading guilty to simple battery in February 2023 and receiving 12 months of probation, Olivia was arrested again in April and admitted to nine probation violations, including missed drug-testing requirements, alongside a warrant alleging a positive fentanyl test. A judge ordered her to serve 45 days in jail, and she spent roughly 22 days behind bars.
- 2024–2026 Bookings: A separate April 2024 license case was eventually dismissed, but Olivia returned to jail on January 9, 2026, on charges of driving on a revoked or suspended license with no tag or insurance, followed by an August 2026 booking in Cobb County for failure to appear.
Now, with her October 27 felony theft by taking arrest representing the highest legal stakes she has faced yet, Olivia’s latest case moves into the Georgia court system—leaving prosecutors and a judge to determine whether the allegations result in a misdemeanor reduction or up to five years behind bars.







