Marshals Season 2 Set Visit Reveals Yellowstone Favorite Jimmy’s Return, Emotional Cast Milestones, and a Massive Train Stunt

When Marshals launched its first season, viewers tuned in expecting to follow Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes) living off the land alongside his wife, Monica (Kelsey Asbille), and their son, Tate (Brecken Merrill). Instead, the Yellowstone sequel series delivered an immediate gut punch by revealing early on that Monica had died—a shocking loss for longtime fans of the franchise. Now, with Season 2 expanded from 13 episodes to a full 20-episode run, a behind-the-scenes visit to the show’s Park City, Utah set has revealed plenty about where the network procedural is heading next, including confirmation that another beloved Yellowstone alum is officially back in the mix.
During a recent press visit to the Utah production hub—which doubles on screen for Montana—cast members Tatanka Means, Arielle Kebbel, Luke Grimes, Brecken Merrill, Ash Santos, and Jefferson White gathered inside the set of The Bullet ’n Barrel Saloon for a casual Q&A. White’s presence alongside the Season 2 ensemble confirmed what fans had been hoping for: Jimmy Hurdstrom is officially returning this season.
Cliffhanger Survivors and the Yellowstone Characters the Cast Misses Most
Heading into Season 2, one of the biggest questions hanging over Marshals was whether Miles Kittle (Tatanka Means) and Andrea Cruz (Ash Santos) had survived Season 1’s tense cliffhanger—a classic television suspense play reminiscent of Dallas’s famous “Who shot J.R.?” mystery. Both actors are indeed back on set, joining Grimes, Kebbel (Belle Skinner), and Logan Marshall-Green, who plays Kayce’s former Navy SEAL teammate and U.S. Marshals unit leader Pete Calvin.
Even with Jimmy’s return confirmed and familiar faces like Thomas Rainwater (Gil Birmingham) and Mo (Mo Brings Plenty) anchoring Kayce’s connection to his past, Monica’s absence is still deeply felt behind the scenes. When reporters asked the cast which former character they would most like to see return—even if only in a flashback—Luke Grimes immediately pointed to Monica, with those who worked alongside Kelsey Asbille agreeing that she is genuinely missed on set. Brecken Merrill lightened the mood with a laugh by naming bunkhouse favorite Teeter (Jen Landon) as his top pick.
Emotional Cast Reflections on Renewal, Representation, and Heat
Landing a 20-episode second season has also brought meaningful personal milestones for the ensemble. While actors often treat renewals as business as usual, Ash Santos grew emotional during the press session while reflecting on how Marshals has changed her life—sharing that the job enabled her to buy her own house.
Away from the saloon set, Gil Birmingham and Mo Brings Plenty sat down with visiting journalists for drinks and offered candid reflections on their journey across both Yellowstone and Marshals. Birmingham drew an intriguing parallel between Rainwater’s dynamic with Kevin Costner’s John Dutton on Yellowstone and the classic crime thriller Heat, pointing out that just like Al Pacino and Robert De Niro in that film, Rainwater and John Dutton actually shared very few scenes together over the course of the flagship series. Meanwhile, Brings Plenty—who grew up without electricity or running water—spoke with quiet gratitude about what it means to be part of the series and represent his people on network television.
Inside the Park City Set: Bullet Holes, Truck-Dragged Boots, and a Train Sequence
Behind the camera, showrunner and creator Spencer Hudnut—a veteran writer from SEAL Team—has successfully guided Kayce Dutton’s transition from cable drama to a fast-paced network procedural. With the writers’ room based outside Utah, the local production and art departments are tasked with bringing whatever the scripts envision to life, even when those ideas bring major logistical hurdles. One of the biggest upcoming set pieces involves a train—a sequence that required careful safety planning and strict adherence to federal regulations.
A walking tour of the facility led by Arielle Kebbel showcased just how much detail goes into building the show’s world:
- Headquarters and Locker Room Details: Kebbel pointed out the main debriefing headquarters as her favorite room on set before leading visitors through the cast locker room—where she spotted her own duffel bag misplaced above Ash Santos’s locker and promptly rearranged it.
- Kayce’s Cabin: Stepping inside Kayce’s cabin revealed lingering continuity from Season 1, with bullet holes from last season still visible in the walls. Production also maintains an exact second replica of the cabin, built inside and out, at another location for exterior filming.
- Costume Department Secrets: Wardrobe designers give every character a distinct style and color palette, while Grimes sticks closely to the signature look he established on Yellowstone. Because stunts, action sequences, and fake blood require multiple identical outfits, the costume team keeps numerous duplicates on hand—and even resorts to rugged tricks like tying new shoes to the back of a truck and dragging them to make them look properly worn.
Watching the crew film even a quiet, three-actor dialogue scene with zero action underscored how painstaking the process remains, as every beat must be captured repeatedly from multiple camera angles before stunt doubles ever step in for high-risk sequences.
With Season 2 roughly 25 percent aired, all scripts completed, and filming moving through the back half of its production schedule, Marshals has firmly hit its stride. As deeper character backstories, potential romances, high-stakes danger, and Jimmy’s return converge across the rest of the 20-episode season, viewers have plenty of reasons to keep watching how Kayce and his team handle whatever comes down the tracks next.







