Chicago Fire: Matthew Daddario Set to Return as McCaffrey After Firehouse 51 Dismissal—Will He Seek Redemption or Hold a Grudge?

Just weeks after his abrupt dismissal from Firehouse 51 made it look like his time in the Windy City was finished for good, Matthew Daddario is heading back to Chicago Fire. The actor will soon reprise his role as McCaffrey, bringing an unexpected follow-up to one of the season’s earliest disciplinary fallouts.
Word of Daddario’s return surfaced through a recently circulated casting call seeking a stand-in matching the actor’s build for camera blocking and lighting tests, listed under the billing “SI McCaffrey.” While the exact episode number for his comeback remains under wraps, filming is slated to begin this week—meaning the installment is not expected to air until after the upcoming One Chicago crossover scheduled for January 13.
How Episode 3 Ended McCaffrey’s Run at Firehouse 51
When viewers last saw McCaffrey in the third episode of the current season, his career at Firehouse 51 appeared to hit a dead end—and entirely by his own making. During a dangerous call, firefighter Tony suffered an injury after one of the probationary firefighters ignored Lieutenant Stella Kidd’s direct orders on the scene.
An investigation into what went wrong soon revealed that McCaffrey was the probie who had disobeyed Kidd’s command. Rather than stepping forward, owning up to his lapse in judgment, and accepting accountability, McCaffrey attempted to lean on his family connections to sweep the incident under the rug.
That refusal to take responsibility crossed a line neither Kidd nor Lieutenant Kelly Severide was willing to tolerate. Unwilling to let political pull excuse a mistake that put a veteran firefighter in harm’s way, Kidd and Severide moved forward with recommending McCaffrey’s dismissal from the Chicago Fire Department—a decision that seemed to close the book on Daddario’s stint on the series.
How the 300th Episode Quietly Opened the Door for His Return
The twist that paved the way for McCaffrey’s return arrived during Chicago Fire’s milestone 300th episode, tangled inside an emotional battle to help one of Firehouse 51’s most beloved veterans. As Mouch and Severide fought to secure an extension for Joe Cruz ahead of his occupational health evaluation, Chief Tomlin saw an opportunity to use his leverage.
Although Tomlin had not been able to shield McCaffrey from the immediate fallout of his Episode 3 actions, the chief agreed to grant Cruz’s extension on one strict condition: Severide had to rescind his dismissal letter to the Deputy Commissioner and have McCaffrey reinstated.
Severide refused to simply hand McCaffrey his old spot back without consequences, yet he proposed a calculated middle ground. Instead of returning straight to an active rig, Severide offered to help place McCaffrey in a front-desk position with the CFD’s equipment and supply team. The compromise put McCaffrey back on the department payroll while forcing him to earn his way back into the field from the ground up.
Even though Cruz ultimately decided to walk away from the CFD on his own terms, the agreement between Severide and Tomlin appeared to hold—Severide secured the extension for Cruz, meaning he rescinded his letter to the Deputy Commissioner and McCaffrey was presumably offered the desk role at equipment and supply.
Redemption Arc or Lingering Resentment?
With Daddario stepping back in front of the cameras this week, the writers are officially walking through the narrative door that Episode 300 cracked open. Having McCaffrey stationed within the CFD’s equipment and supply division creates an organic reason for him to cross paths with Firehouse 51 personnel again—setting up an intriguing test of character once he comes face-to-face with Severide and Kidd.
The biggest question heading into his return is how McCaffrey has handled his demotion behind the scenes. Working the front desk is a far cry from riding on a Firehouse 51 rig, and viewers will be watching closely to see whether the assignment has humbled him enough to learn from his mistakes and kick off a genuine redemption arc—or if he will resurface nursing a grudge against the two lieutenants who held him accountable in the first place.







